A co-produced qualitative study exploring how procedural justice principles can improve forensic mental health patients' involvement in decisions about their care.
Project Title: The ENGAGE Study: A co-produced interview study of forensic mental health patients’ engagement in care using a procedural justice theoretical framework
Lead Researcher: Dr Jack Tomlin, Affiliated Researcher
Funder: British Academy / Leverhulme Trust
Project Duration: 2 January 2024 - 31 December 2025
Overview
Inpatient and community forensic mental health services provide care for people with mental health needs who have offended or are at high risk of harm to themselves or others — a setting where patients experience many restrictions that those in general psychiatric care do not. The ENGAGE Study examines one of the most significant of these: limited involvement in decision-making. Many important decisions are made on behalf of forensic patients — including whether to go into involuntary care, to change hospitals, whether they can see their children, or which activities they can participate in. The project applies procedural justice theory to this context, proposing that where people feel the procedures used to arrive at a decision were fair, evidence-based, neutral, and gave them a voice, they are more likely to collaborate with authorities.
Objectives
The overarching research question is: in what ways can a procedural justice approach help us to understand and improve forensic mental health patients' engagement in care? The study aims to identify the factors that help or hinder patient involvement in decision-making, and to generate concrete actions that staff working across forensic services can deploy to involve patients in a supportive, safe, respectful, and empowering way.
Key Activities / Outputs
The study used a qualitative methodology to conduct in-depth interviews with 15 patients and 14 staff members across two medium-secure hospitals in London, analysed using Constant Comparative Analysis.
From this work, the team developed the PARTNER framework — identifying seven principles of procedurally fair involvement: Professionalism, Advocacy, Representative fairness, Transparent information, Neutrality, Empathy, and Recognition of voice. When staff acted in accordance with these principles, patients reported feeling treated like a human being, leading to feelings of dignity, hope, and engagement in treatment.
The study was co-produced throughout, with a Lived Experience Engagement Team involved in conducting the project and two co-investigators with lived experience of forensic care, coordinated with the South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust Involvement Register.
Collaborators
The ENGAGE Study was conducted in partnership with two medium-secure NHS Trusts in London. The project's co-production model involves a Lived Experience Engagement Team coordinated with the South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust Involvement Register.
More Information
For full study details, visit the Health Research Authority research summary at hra.nhs.uk/planning-and-improving-research/application-summaries/research-summaries/the-engage-study-2